The Real Madrid honor guard snub that shocked the football world this week was more than a simple breach of tradition – it was a public display of power that raises the question of whether players are being given more power than they should.

When Kylian Mbappe’s Real Madrid turned down his manager’s call to play for Barcelona after winning 3-2 in the Spanish Super Cup final, it felt like the players had a bigger say in the team than the manager.

Days after the incident, reports emerged that Xabi Alonso would leave Real Madrid as head coach and be replaced by former defender Alvaro Arbeloa. Some believe the former Bayern Leverkusen boss’ departure was due to the embarrassment of public scorn he faced, a sign that he could no longer manage the egos and personalities within Real Madrid’s squad.

In most leagues around the world, honor guards are considered sacred. It was at that moment that the game was paused for a few minutes and each team paid tribute to their opponent’s sporting achievements.

However, in the Spanish Super Cup final, this unwritten rule was trampled on, and Mbappe became the central figure. His impact could not be ignored as he signaled his teammates and head coach to leave the area where the guard of honor was located.

The question of who’s responsible: Was Xavi Alonso sacked because of Real Madrid’s player rights?

What makes Real Madrid’s honor guard snub even more fascinating is its timing and the characters involved. Xabi Alonso is a coach known for discipline, structure and collective responsibility – as demonstrated during his two-and-a-half years in Germany – and his aim is to turn Madrid into a unified, well-oiled machine.

But as his players casually walk through Barcelona, ​​it raises a more troubling question: How much control does Alonso really have when global superstars like Kylian Mbappe, Rodrygo and Vinicius can make other decisions? Will this trend continue when Florentino Perez decides to appoint another coach?

In addition, Mbappe, who led the strike, is not the captain or vice-captain. These positions traditionally have the highest power in the team after the coach. The Frenchman didn’t even start and didn’t come on until the 76th minute.

It shows how influential the player is now at Real Madrid: a substitute without the captain’s armband can still set the tone for a moment that represents unity and respect.

Agreed, Mbappe is their talisman and has been a big-name signing since joining the club, but at every stage of elite football there are hierarchies and chains of power that must be respected. No individual, no matter how influential, may override the collective standards of the institution.

Barcelona react to Real Madrid’s unsporting behavior: Laporta’s comments about snubbing Real Madrid honor guard

After the incident, Barcelona president Laporta expressed his views on the controversy, expressing disappointment with the attitude shown by Mbappe and his teammates after the final. He said:

“I was surprised by his approach. You have to be generous and respectful when you win or when you lose. This is sport and you have to behave normally. I believe we are generous and respectful when we win. That’s why I can’t understand it.”

Mbappe and his team-mates led Real Madrid’s honor guard to snub Barcelona, ​​setting a negative precedent for youth teams and, if this model is followed, it will certainly damage the spirit of the sport.

You may also like: Harry Wilson’s form: Fulham player to watch

Conflict cuts Alonso’s tenure at Madrid short

Xabi Alonso’s reign at Real Madrid lasted just seven months, a period marked by recurring tensions and growing friction within the squad. These conflicts, not just the results themselves, ultimately led to the premature end of his tenure.

Fede Valverde publicly expressed his dissatisfaction with being deployed at right-back at the start of the season, while Vinicius Junior had a heated row with Alonso after being substituted in El Clasico, angrily declaring on the touchline: “I’d better leave.”

Alonso also faced the dissatisfaction of Rodrygo in limited playing time as he struggled tactically to rebalance the squad following the return of Jude Bellingham, particularly in integrating Arda Guler into a coherent system. He has also reportedly pushed for new signings behind the scenes – a request the club has rejected – further straining an already fragile relationship between the manager and the hierarchy.

His successor, former Real Madrid defender Alvaro Arbeloa, has spent his entire coaching career in the club’s youth academy since 2020.

While coaching Castilla, he led the U19 team to a historic treble in the 2022/23 season, winning the league championship, the Youth King’s Cup and the Campenes Cup.

Amid tension among Madrid fans, it forces the question of an age-old debate: does a mid-season sacking actually improve the team’s performance in the coming weeks, or does it bring about a short-lived “new manager bounce”?

If that momentum is enough to help Real Madrid overturn a four-point lead over Barcelona at the top of La Liga, it could be a gamble worth taking.

The snub of Barcelona by Real Madrid’s guard of honor was more than just a refusal to applaud. It was a moment that changed everything – an event that should never have happened. Of course, players and coaches sometimes clash and miscommunication occurs. But what happened in the Spanish Super Cup final was more than a simple misunderstanding. This is a clear and deliberate refusal to obey orders.

Main photo

Credit: imagery / ball original image

Recording date: January 11, 2026